Jerry’s Doctoral Dissertation

An Exploration of Rates and Causes of Attrition Among Protestant Evangelical Clergy in the United States

Download Full PDF

Hon. D.D., St. Thomas Christian College, 2010
M. Div., Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, 2009
Hon. D.D., Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary, 1997
Hon. D.D., Christian Bible College, 1988

ABSTRACT Many surveys indicate that a skyrocketing number of American clergy are leaving the ministry—as many as 1,500 per month. Moral failure among pastors is at an all-time high with six–nine pastors committing adultery or involved in sexual misconduct every hour, 165–205 clerics every day. These catastrophic numbers do not include associate staff ministers who are being terminated, for a wide variety of reasons, at a rate double that of senior pastors. “An Exploration of Rates and Causes of Attrition Among Protestant Evangelical Clergy in the United States” examines why the tragic trend line has progressed so negatively. Further, to get at the core problems, this thesis defines the causes and the cure of moral failure and provides six case studies. How does the documented decline of church attendance in the U.S. impact the longevity of pastors? Is there a connection between archaic church polity and congregational conflict in the demise of pastors? The author provides a compelling personal story of perseverance in ministry. Why is the pastoral vocation in the list of the top ten occupations in which people suffer from heart disease, along with scores of other physical and emotional maladies? As an antidote to the multiple challenges and problems in ministry, the thesis recommends solutions and challenges in each area such that pastors may be protected, graciously supported, and held accountable to fulfill their noble calling.








CHAPTER 1 Pastoral Attrition and Personal Motivation

CHAPTER 2 The High Casualty Rate Among Pastors

CHAPTER 3 The Causes and Cures of the Moral Failure of Pastors

CHAPTER 4 Why are People Leaving the Church?

CHAPTER 5 The Health Challenges of Leaders

CHAPTER 6 Soul Care



APPENDIX A Restorative Procedures of the Assembly of God

APPENDIX B Bylaws Bylaws—Elder/Church Representation Governance

APPENDIX C Kansas Attorney General Subpoena

APPENDIX D Attorney’s Initial Response of 2-Year Ordeal

APPENDIX E Kansas Department of Revenue Letter

APPENDIX F Kansas Corruption by Former Attorney General Phill Kline

APPENDIX G Response of Board Chairman Judge Robert Ulrich

APPENDIX H The Definition of the Separation of Church and State by David Barton (Published on

APPENDIX I Ingram’s Business Magazine Editor Letter

APPENDIX J Sebelius-Tiller Political Connections



Latest Blog Posts


3-Year Documentary Filming by Jerry and Cristie Jo Johnston

Over 100 iconic atheist, leaders in atheism, agnosticism, secularism, sociology, philosophy, apologetics, nones, dones, and deconversions have filmed with Cristie Jo and me for our upcoming documentary and ancillary products….


Cristie Johnston interviews Nabeel Qureshi

Nabeel Quershi is the author of Seeking Allah, Finding Jesus. It is his personal story where he transitioned from a committed Muslim to a follower of Jesus Christ. The book…


Jerry & Cristie Johnston Interview Frank Schaeffer … A Self-Described Atheist Who Prays?

We learned something interesting in our two-hour filmed interview with self-identified atheist Frank Schaeffer, son of the late theologian Francis Schaeffer. Frank told us that he prays. FRANK SCHAEFFER:  “When I pray in…

Follow me on Twitter